I just finished deleting emails in my inbox. This task has become more and more of a struggle as the spam emails have increased. But, as I was moving 250 emails into my Junk Mail folder in the hopes that our new filter would learn and move them there itself, I was struck by some of the subject lines. Become a better you, The women won’t leave you alone, Be her superstar and a few more that I cannot repeat. Here is what struck me. I wouldn’t have to wade through this garbage if somebody wasn’t buying it. It’s a matter of supply and demand. Someone is paying for the pills or buying the creams in order to Increase their Manliness. As an aside, if you’re reading this and it’s you who’s doing it, STOP. Please, for the love of all that is decent, stop buying the stuff so my Inbox doesn’t get so full!
But, someone is buying these things. Why? What would possess someone to purchase enlargement medication that has not been declared safe by any drug agency this side of a shady ally in some far away country? Here’s why – perfection. Someone out there thinks having a larger penis is going to make them irresistible to the ladies. Someone out there believes the standard of perfection lies in their pants. The flip side is also true in female circles. Ladies everywhere are buying bust enhancement medication under the false belief that larger breasts will make them perfect. I guess the reasoning is if their breasts are perfect then they can land them the perfect man with the large, perfect penis. Who knows?
So, what does all this have to do with the perfect youth pastor? Well, when it comes to churches across the U.S. many have bought the pills. They have ridiculous ideas concerning what makes a perfect youth pastor. Many have extremely unrealistic expectations. The same insanity applies to the expectations for all pastors, but this is an article about youth pastors.
Before I start, I want to make it clear that these do not represent the leadership at my current church. The Lord has given me and my family a wonderful church in which to serve and one that values me and treats me with respect. With that said though, I have known and even served in churches that were looking for the stereotypical traits they believed made a perfect youth pastor. Below are just a few.
Myth #1
The perfect youth pastor must be between 22 and 35 years old in order to relate to youth.
I have two friends who were “let go” from a church in which they had collectively served for over 20 years. Coincidentally, they were both about the same age when the leadership of their church found a reason to “ask” for their resignations. Some investigation revealed that the leadership of said church had bought into the erroneous belief that good youth pastors can’t relate well to youth if they are over 35. These two guys were loved by their students and very effective at what they were doing, but that didn’t matter to the men who supposedly knew better.
Sadly, this happens in many churches. The leadership comes to the conclusion that a youth pastor must be as close to the age of the youth as possible in order to be effective. They use the logic that students need someone with whom they can relate and only young youth pastors have that ability. This is ridiculous and can be damaging on many levels. It is also illogical.
No one would even begin to suggest that the Children’s Pastor be close to the age of the children. If that were the case, we’d be hiring 16-year-olds to run our children’s ministries. But, when it comes to student ministry or even college-age ministry, this standard seems perfectly acceptable.
Why? Simply put, those who hold this view don’t know what makes someone an effective pastor to begin with. What makes an effective pastor is someone who loves God and loves people. They enter the world of the people in their church. They go out to lunch with them. They spend time with them and their families. They call them. They know them. What makes and effective youth pastor is someone who is willing to enter into the world of teens. We hang out with them. We have MySpace and Facebook accounts (sometimes). We go to their schools. We attend their football games. We hang out with them and play Xbox. We find ways to show them we are interested in them. We call them and we know them.
Students are no different than most adults. They want a pastor who shows interest in them. They want a pastor who at least makes an attempt to understand them. They want someone who loves them and knows them. When we do that, we earn the right to speak truth into their lives.
It doesn’t matter if a youth pastor is 20 or 50. If they are willing to do the hard work of building relationships then they can be an effective youth pastor. If we are unwilling to do that, we will be ineffective no matter what our age.
Myth #2
The perfect youth pastor must be a dynamic, entertaining speaker
As a pastor, the ability to speak well is a plus, but it is not a requirement. I’ve sat under some very good speakers. They connected with their audience. They kept their audience interested. But, when the message was over, they hid away in their office and made no attempt to connect with people on a personal level. When someone was hurting, they dismissed their hurt. When someone needed counsel, they shared it, but with little sympathy or empathy. They never sat still long enough to have a meaningful conversation with the people they were supposedly leading and as a result, they were not very effective shepherds.
I’ve also sat under some pretty average speakers. They didn’t connect well. They had a hard time communicating their message. But, they were loved by the people they taught. Why? Because they had compassion. They were genuinely interested in people and what was going on in their lives. Consequently, when they gave an average sermon, people listened because they knew they were loved. The Shepherd knows his sheep and those who are called to shepherd the Shepherd’s sheep don’t need to be the most dynamic, entertaining speaker in order to lead those sheep. They need to know them.
A good youth pastor doesn’t have to be an amazing speaker. They don’t have to be a captivating, dynamic, funny communicator. They do have to be able to communicate in some form or another, but the hour or so they teach each week is not nearly as important as the time they spend throughout the rest of the week making phone calls, eating lunch, hanging out and simply showing interest in their students. When we do that, we earn their trust and they will be much more willing to listen to an average lesson from us because they know they are loved.
Myth #3
The perfect youth pastor relates well with every student.
Over the last 14 years I have heard many complaints from parents about their teen’s youth pastor. One of the most unfair is “my child doesn’t get much from the youth ministry. The youth pastor doesn’t connect well with him/her.”
While that may be a valid complaint, the subsequent solution is not as valid. The solution usually involves complaining to the lead pastor or a select few other parents who then come to the conclusion that the church needs a new youth pastor simply because he does not relate well to a small number of students.
I’ve been on this earth for 37 years. Over that time I have come to realize one thing; I will never please everyone. As likeable as I think I am, not everyone will like me. As funny as I think I am, not everyone will laugh at my jokes. Not everyone will like the way I teach. Unfortunately though, I have discovered that there are many people who expect me to relate well with every human being between the ages of 11 and 19. I once had an adult from another church tell me they needed a youth pastor like me. They had heard me speak and came to the insane conclusion that every student in the room adored me. I suppose they then reasoned that I must be able to connect with every student. I still laugh when I think of that conversation because I can point to dozens of students over the years that I had absolutely no connection with whatsoever. No matter how hard I tried, they did not respond to me.
Youth pastors do not possess a supernatural ability to connect with every teenager. In fact, I frequently tell parents not to expect me to fix their child…I may make things worse!
One thing we have working against us is that many of our students have no choice about where they go to church. Their parents can pick and choose a church based on their personal preferences and whether or not they like the pastor. If they don’t connect with the pastor, they most likely find a new church to attend. Their children don’t have that same luxury for the most part. They go to church where their parents go which means they are “stuck” with a youth pastor they may not relate with well.
Church leaders would be wise to remember this the next time they hear complaints from a small few about their youth pastor’s ability to relate. They would be wise to view the ministry as a whole and see how well their youth pastor relates to the majority of teens.
Myth #4
The perfect youth pastor is married and his wife is actively involved in the youth ministry.
I was a single youth pastor for the first six years. I had it good. When I began looking for a full-time position in which to serve, I was amazed at how many churches required that their youth pastor be married. I asked a few of those churches to give me their rationale for that requirement and none of them made any sense to me. Below are three of those rationales and a little commentary to let you know what I think:
1. A married youth pastor will be less likely to get involved with a student.
WHAT? How many married pastors have had affairs? How many married pastors have gotten emotionally involved with a member of their church or youth ministry? The sad truth is many have gone down this road and it had nothing to do with their marital status and everything to do with the condition of their heart and their commitment to remaining above reproach.
Whether married or single, a good youth pastor will have safeguards in place to guard his heart. He will be accountable. He will have a desire to live a holy life. Marriage does not cure one of lust or wandering eyes.
2. A married youth pastor will be less likely to be involved in porn.
Ha ha! See above.
3. A married youth pastor’s wife will be able to help him with the youth group.
Like I said, I was single for the first six years as a youth pastor. During that time I only had to deal with the expectations placed on me. Those expectations were sometimes unfair and difficult to deal with, but they were nothing compared with the expectations some people place on the wives of youth pastors.
My wife is one of the godliest women I know. She deeply loves Jesus and deeply loves people. But, when we got married, she had no interest in working with teens. I was fine with that, but some leaders in the church were not and they hurt her with some of their expectations and the way they verbalized them.
A youth pastor’s wife does not have to love working with teens. She should be supportive of his ministry and encourage him in his calling, but she doesn’t have to be called to it as well.
Myth #5
The perfect youth pastor must be “cool” in order to relate well to teens.
This is closely tied with Myth #1, but the older I get, the more uncool I become. That was a hard truth to grasp, but it is truth. When I was 20, I was still kind of cool. Now that I am nearing 40, my coolness has diminished considerably. I can try to look cool. I can dress like my students, but the older I get the creepier that looks.
A good youth pastor doesn’t have to be cool. He doesn’t have to listen to the newest music, have all the up-to-date clothes or watch the same movies. All he needs to do is love his students and coolness has nothing to do with performing that task.
I have a few others, but that should be a good starting point. Feel free to add your own to the list.